Agree:

Open uri20180605 4 16g116w?1528193478

Harris Miller American politician

The machines performed beautifully ... Instead of theories about catastrophes, the simple reality is that the machines produce accurate results and the voters love them.
Open uri20180528 4 1uetub7?1527478370

Michael Shamos American mathematician

Technology is always required in elections. The days of the hand-counted ballots are over. You can design technology in a way that makes the problems readily apparent or that they're disguised. My position is that when a problem is found, it's an engineering problem.
Open uri20180605 4 pmubww?1528195545

John Bercow Speaker of the House of Commons

I don't mean by that that it will necessarily at any stage be compulsory to vote in that way, but I think that the notion that, if it can be established as secure and reliable, people should have the option to vote online, will gain ground more and more and more.
Open uri20180605 4 5l224c?1528192536

Ted Selker Computer scientist

Numerous pieces of evidence suggest that electronic voting machines outperformed all other methods used [in the 2004 US presidential election].
Open uri20180528 4 12bqajy?1527475685

Narendra Modi Prime Minister of India

On one hand, there are parties that have lagged behind in technology, either they cannot understand or are purposely spreading lies. They have opposed all subjects in technology — EVM, Aadhaar card, mobile phone, every where.
Open uri20180521 4 14258sa?1526882323

Malcolm Turnbull Australian politician and prime minister

I think we considerably overestimate the security of the current paper voting system and we also overestimate the insecurity of electronic voting systems.
Open uri20180521 4 1vygl4a?1526882126

Bill Shorten Australian politician

We're a grown up democracy - it shouldn't be taking eight days to find out who won and who lost. We can't afford to let Australia drift for eight days after an election.
Open uri20180528 4 1d0w303?1527476158

Kersti Kaljulaid President of Estonia | Eesti Vabariigi president

In addition to having a really secure personal identification system, which is a physical card, and two codes – I think, frankly, it's slightly stronger than somebody opening my passport with my photo that is six years old. We have made the system even stronger by the fact that e-voting lasts several days.
Open uri20180528 4 1oqsoqi?1527473944

Sania Nishtar Pakistani cardiologist

On balance, internet voting is feasible, which if effectively deployed, could improve accessibility for voters, especially those that are overseas and others for whom access is an issue, such as the disabled. It could also potentially save costs and time.
Open uri20180528 4 3nosz?1527478989

Antonio Mugica Smartmatic CEO and member of SGO, investing in Democracy, E-voting, Privacy and Identity, and

The reason to bring technology into the election process is to increase integrity and security, but it has a series of important collateral benefits. One is cost reduction: so I’m sure Britain could spend less per election if it was using technology, and the security and integrity would be 10 to a hundredfold better. So you have something that’s a hundredfold better, and it’s going to cost less... See More
Open uri20180605 4 h0tp8d?1528195741

WebRoots Democracy WebRoots Democracy is a think tank focused on the intersection of technology and democratic pa

There have been more instances of fraud across the world with paper votes than electronic ones, and the recent recounts of electronic votes in the US showed no evidence of hacking.
Open uri20180528 4 12q2iop?1527480868

Dominion Voting Systems Dominion is a different kind of election company - more than a vendor, we are a partner who un

Dominion has invested in the development of proprietary technology that truly sets its products apart from the competition. Focusing on two key aspects of the electoral process – risk-limiting auditing and voter intent – Dominion's technology improves the transparency and integrity of the election process.

Disagree:

Open uri20180528 4 1w04sl0?1527476551

David Dill Computer scientist

The way I look at things is: How many people have to conspire to steal an election now? With paper ballots at polling places, to steal a significant number of votes, you’d have to have lots of poll workers or a lot of voters voting fraudulently, which would be very difficult and expensive. And with paperless touchscreen voting you maybe need a few programmers. If you had widespread Internet voting... See More
Open uri20180528 4 xopl45?1527480724

Ron Rivest Cryptographer

We have learned the hard way that almost any computer system can be broken into by a sufficiently determined, skillful, and persistent adversary. There is nothing special about voting systems that magically provides protection against attack... Voting system software may be maliciously designed, may contain bugs, or may be changed or replaced at some point during the pre-election roll-out of eq... See More
Open uri20180521 4 euz07s?1526883336

Lawrence Norden Deputy Director of the Democracy Program at the Brennan Center for Justice

If you have machines not working, or working slowly, that could create lots of problems too, preventing people from voting at all.
Open uri20180621 4 1h35395?1529617703

Donald J. Trump President of the USA

It's old-fashioned — but it's always good to have a paper back-up system of voting.
Open uri20180605 4 wbwtx9?1528197012

Bill Clinton Founder, Clinton Foundation and 42nd President of the United States. Follow @clintonfdn for 

Until we get this [electronic voting] straightened out, every state should go to some sort of paper ballot system.
Open uri20180521 4 lqqncb?1526880890

Bruce Schneier Bruce Schneier is an internationally renowned security technologist and author. Described by T

Today, we conduct our elections on computers. Our registration lists are in computer databases. We vote on computerized voting machines. And our tabulation and reporting is done on computers. We do this for a lot of good reasons, but a side effect is that elections now have all the insecurities inherent in computers. The only way to reliably protect elections from both malice and accident is to us... See More
Open uri20180528 4 1via2h4?1527477914

Michael Geist Law Professor & Canada Research Chair in Internet and E-commerce Law @uocommonlaw @uOttawaTech

While technology may someday allow us to replicate these essential features online, many of them are currently absent from Internet voting, which is subject to any number of possible disruptions. These include denial of service attacks that shut down the election process, counterfeit websites, phishing attacks, hacks into the election system, or the insertion of computer viruses that tamper with e... See More
Open uri20180605 4 xszy7i?1528197278

Matt Blaze Scientist, safecracker, professor, writer. 280 is the new 140 is the new 1536.

Few, if any, state and local IT departments are equipped to protect this infrastructure against the full force of a hostile intelligence service, and these systems are very attractive targets for disruption.
Data?1526882888

Bill Thompson I'm a hack and pundit. I appear on Click on BBC World Service radio. Helping design a future B

I do not think it is possible to design an e-voting system that can be guaranteed secure against a concerted and well-funded attack. I am concerned that this will happen, or worse, that it will be suspected and that the results of an election will be cast into doubt.
Open uri20180605 4 b0t9di?1528195151

Ed Felten Robert E. Kahn Professor of Computer Science & Public Affairs @Princeton. Formerly Deputy U.S.

If there is uncertainty after an election, either because of the possibility of tampering or just the possibility of error or malfunction, a paperless system like Georgia’s doesn’t have any way to go back to other evidence to figure out what really happened.
Data?1527476636

Kathy Sheridan Journalist with The Irish Times.

In the early 2000s, the then taoiseach Bertie Ahern said we were a “laughing stock” with our use of the “peann luaidhe”, and so the Fianna Fáil lads fluttered €51 million on electronic voting machines with no paper trail or independent verification. Trust the lads, was the message. Without the combined firepower of media, experts like Margaret McGaley and thinking politicians, we too might be livi... See More
Open uri20180521 4 1pohhcm?1526881164

Ross Anderson British computer scientist, cryptographer

When you move from voting in person to voting at home (whether by post, by phone or over the internet) it vastly expands the scope for vote buying and coercion, and we’ve seen this rising steadily in the UK since the 2001 election where postal votes first became a right. All the parties have been caught hustling up the vote in various ways.
Open uri20180605 4 hnngha?1528194411

Debra Bowen CA Secretary of State, 2007-15. Not in elected office - and adjusting.

When I took office, I commissioned a top-to-bottom review of all our voting systems: paper-based optical scan systems, as well as the e-voting or touchscreen systems. The University of California took the lead, and it involved universities and private-sector people from around the country. I have about 700 pages of documentation that are publicly available on my Web site, and I had another private... See More
Open uri20180605 4 14yoznk?1528193725

Verified Voting Foundation Advocating for transparent election processes and verifiable voting systems.

Far too many states use unreliable and insecure electronic voting machines, and many states have made their situation worse by adding some forms of Internet voting for some voters, which cannot be checked for accuracy at all. Even in states where verifiable systems are used, too often the check on the voting system's function and accuracy is not done. The voting equipment now in use are aging; res... See More
Open uri20180528 4 1sf5vnr?1527480432

Alex Halderman Professor of computer science and engineering at @UMich. Security and privacy, election securi

Machines [are] stored around the country [India] in a variety of locations, from abandoned warehouses to schools, etc. [and it is] likely many of them could be accessed by criminals, especially with the aid of dishonest insiders.
Open uri20180528 4 sbw9ks?1527477008

Avi Rubin Computer Science Professor at Johns Hopkins, researching computer security. Father of three. R

My position hasn't changed over the years. Which is that online voting is a very unsafe idea and a very bad idea and something I think no technological breakthrough I can foresee can ever change. People's computers are not getting more secure. They're getting more infected with viruses. They're getting more under the control of malware.
Open uri20180605 4 1n6ctor?1528195917

John Sawers Former M16 chief

The more things that go online, the more susceptible you are to cyberattacks.
Open uri20180521 4 npzucu?1526881507

Jimmy Carter American politician, 39th president of the united states (in office from 1977 to 1981)

Technology is being introduced into electoral processes to promote efficiency, but it also moves voting and counting into the unobservable digital realm. In the Netherlands, electronic voting has been abandoned amid concerns about foreign interference in elections. During the 2016 presidential campaign in the United States, Russian hackers broke into the Democratic National Committee’s email syste... See More
Create a new topic or join us from £2/year